Brooklyn has emerged as the production's most sustained on-location chapter. The most specific confirmed Brooklyn address is Norman Avenue in Greenpoint – with behind-the-scenes images showing the famous pink house at 61 Norman Avenue clearly visible in the background as Stone and Pine filmed scenes on the street.
On September 11, Stone and Pine were spotted filming a kiss scene on a Friday night in Brooklyn. Earlier the same day, Stone filmed gardening scenes while getting notes from director McCary. The Brooklyn location work extends back through August, when Stone filmed alongside Tim Robbins and Ashley Padilla in the borough, with Pine and Druski also spotted in the area around the same time.
Around September 13, the production filmed at the South Street Seaport in Lower Manhattan – the historic waterfront district on the East River whose 19th-century mercantile buildings, wooden piers and views across to Brooklyn Bridge give it a visual character entirely unlike the rest of downtown Manhattan.
Yellow production signs appeared in Dutchess County in the Hudson Valley under the code name Keychain – confirmed by local sources as The Catch
Washington State is confirmed as the production's second major location – its Pacific Northwest character providing a visual and emotional contrast to New York's baseball intensity.
The Catch opens in cinemas on May 21, 2027.
