Principal photography began on November 5, 2025, in Atlanta, and continued for several weeks before wrapping in December. The production was based at Tyler Perry Studios – the 330-acre facility on the former Fort McPherson military base at One Tyler Perry Studio Way. The studio complex includes twelve purpose-built sound stages and permanent standing sets: a bank, a courtroom, a police station, a prison yard, residential blocks, the White House. The backlot can become any American city without leaving the property line.
For The Gospel of Christmas, the production team used the studio’s New York City streetscape – a permanent architectural set on the backlot, constructed to mimic the blocks, facades and sidewalks of a New York neighbourhood. The trailer shows Isaac and Rebecca standing outside their inherited church on a street filled with graffiti, trash and a car on cinder blocks. None of it is New York. All of it is a backlot in southwest Atlanta, designed and dressed to look like a borough that exists only on camera.